The Bread Loaf Diaries
A novelist’s record of many years spent at the famed summer conference reveals the joys to be found in the company of fellow writers and
The first Bread Loaf Writers’ Conference was held in Ripton, Vermont, under the auspices of Middlebury College and with the encouragement of Robert Frost, 100 years ago this August. I taught fiction writing at the conference during 11 summers between 1996 and 2016, the era when the poet Michael Collier was director.
I was 44 when I first arrived “on the mountain,” as conferees say, and I always took along my diary, making a record of Bread Loaf’s frantic routine of lectures, workshops, student conferences, readings, cocktail parties, and dancing.
The writer friends who most often appear in these entries are the novelists Andrea Barrett, Richard Bausch, Charles Baxter, Lynn Freed, and Margot Livesey; the poets Edward Hirsch, Ellen Bryant Voigt, and Michael Collier; and the memoirist Patricia Hampl.
The “Fellows” were writers who had published their first books and now assisted the faculty; the “waiters” were the winners of highly competitive work-scholarships, an elite corps that participated in all the activities listed above, while also serving meals to the conference’s participants in the dining room of the Bread Loaf Inn.
1996
August 13: Had dinner with Andrea [Barrett], Michael Collier (the very sweet, toothy new director, who’s been brought in to dismantle some of the old comical hierarchies here), and Margot Livesey, an old friend of Andrea’s, very brisk, Scotch, chummy.
August 17: I’m struck by how much better behaved writers are to one another up here. In New York all the talk would be about contracts, reviews, who’s up, who’s down, but enough about you, let’s talk about me. Here everything is sort of loose and silly, with even a word or two about writing (as opposed to the Writing Life) thrown in.
August 18: … Lunch was a picnic at Frost’s old summer house on the way toward Ripton. I walked home from that, stopping in the little graveyard on the southern side of the road. One marker for two young men, brothers, Winfield and Perley Smith, not twins but each about twenty. Both died in 1894, Winfield in January (“Killed by an overturning log wagon” is the explanation carved into the modest obelisk) and Perley on July 4: “Killed by the explosion of a cannon.” At an Independence Day celebration? Could it be anything else? Well, here is God’s plenty, a whole other novel waiting for me if I ever need one.
August 19: Had a conference with Will Allison, a bright boy in my workshop. He said that everybody up here claims to be “looking for my voice,” whereas he’s looking for his subject matter.
August 20: Aside from the workshop I had to do a “class” today—on using journals in fiction—and when that was over and I’d folded my laundry I just hit a wall and keeled over. Fell asleep and missed the afternoon reading. Surprised it hasn’t happened before now, as I don’t think I’ve had more than six hours’ sleep on any night since coming up here.
August 21: [Richard] Bausch joke: A writer drives home, sees his house has burned down. Gets out of car and asks wife sitting on smoldering porch what happened. “It’s so strange,” she cries. “Three hours ago your agent came here, doused the house with gasoline, and set it afire.” Smiling and excited, the writer replies: “My agent came to my house?!”
Grace Paley the afternoon’s guest reader … This awful, sentimental cultishness that she inspires. She was pleasant and matter-of-fact enough, but I underwent no conversion.
August 23: Afternoon readings by cute, clever Greg Williamson (I’ve decided he’ll be the physical model for my young astronomer in Two Moons) and Annie Lamott, who read some funny, ultimately sentimental stuff about writing that drove Maureen Howard up the wall.
Rain forced the big cocktail party into the barn. … All week there’s been a sort of running joke, a parlor game about what famous literary titles might be improved by the addition of [the word] “fucking.” (Among the best: The Fucking Idiot.)
Fell asleep after dinner, but I did make it to the second waiters’ reading. Michael took me back to the video-and-lighting booth and showed me the bust of Frost hanging in a noose, like a sandbag.
1997
August 13: Had breakfast with Michael … whose handsome laugh lines will look like something on Lillian Hellman’s face by the end of the two weeks. Still, he’s hoping things won’t be too placid. I could see him looking around the dining hall for the half-crazy straw that will stir the drink.
Andrea’s reading … She is the conference queen this year—or princess royal—and they could have carried her in on a sedan chair. [The previous November, she had won the National Book Award for Fiction for her collection Ship Fever.] A great burst of applause as she got to the mike. She read “The Littoral Zone” (a perfect story for a conference over which adultery hovers) …
Sandy Solomon, an affable left poet, was the other reader. She magnified her mistakes and slips of the tongue with eye rollings and jeezes—not a good idea here, where the audience evaluates the performance as much as the work.
August 14: The first two-hour workshop in the Barn. My, they’re contentious! They really went after a chapter by Greg Cowles, and as usual some of the weaker students are the harshest critics. Greg is one of the better and nicest [writers] (and, what his classmates don’t know, a [fiction] reader for Bill Buford at The New Yorker).
August 15: Afternoon reading: [Agha] Shahid [Ali], who was charming and outrageous and made his performance into a giant personal ad.
August 16: … ran into Michael this morning and he said he was “looking for a weapon” with which to kill Lois Rosenthal [the editor of Story], who is beyond impossible, demanding boxed lunches, air fares, better placement of Story’s contest rules.
August 18: During one of my conferences this morning, Nancy Spear, a [Middlebury] faculty wife who’s in my class, mentioned that she’d given [my novel] Henry and Clara to her father, who “writes books on legal issues” and is doing one on Lincoln’s suspension of habeas corpus. She says he really liked the book and is now reading Dewey [Defeats Truman]. I asked her what his name is. “William Rehnquist,” she answered. “He’s the Chief Justice.”
August 20: [Late at night] … a high-speed, screaming van ride through the Green Mountain National Forest. The ten or so of us along (Andrea, too) woke up every piece of wildlife, and eventually, upon our return, the whole campus.
August 23: I was too tired to stay up beyond 2:20 a.m. (This sentence may sound laughable, but not at Bread Loaf.)
1999
August 10: Michael was coming up [Rte.] 125 when we pulled up to the Inn. And it seemed that, in minutes, Dickie and Karen and Alan Shapiro and Howard Norman and Jane Shore were all there [as well]. We stood on the sidewalk, happily jabbering. Andrea arrived, too, having sweet-talked her way out of a $200 speeding ticket from a Vermont cop.
I met Jhumpa Lahiri, my Fellow and the latest It girl (Michiko K. raved about her stories last Friday), during pre-dinner drinks. She’s quite beautiful and deliberate—whether from shyness or something more regal, I’m not yet sure.
August 11: The place is packed. They’ve over-admitted this year, and it’s a drag trying to get a seat at dinner that isn’t between two students eager to tell you their life stories.
August 12: My workshop has a geriatric feel … these older ones tend to be hopeless. The young go-getters regard them as pathetic, and whatever status they have in the outside world—corporate lawyer, economics professor—seems utterly shorn from them [here]. I imagine Jhumpa looking at me and feeling contempt for my over-indulgence of their pathetic efforts—the same way I remember Brady [Udall doing], though it probably hasn’t been so in either case.
Began the day with Trish Hampl’s lecture on memoir. Beautifully shaped, smart and tough-minded; likely to be described as being merely charming because it happens to be that too. She talked about getting away with things in personal non-fiction—coping with real people who feel you’ve betrayed them, etc.
August 13: I conferred with Richard Hoppe, one of my older gentlemen, who tells me he picked me because of my “humanity,” what he detected in A Book of One’s Own and Dewey. It made me realize that I am a better person on paper (this book excluded!) than in life.
August 14: The workshop is going fine. They’re amiable to one another and there’s always a sufficiency of hands in the air, so I’m relaxed. …
The dance felt familiar—happy enough, but without much Eros in the air. Michael and Andrea (after three shots of tequila) danced barefoot on the Barn’s sticky wooden floor. Carol Smith has arrived from New York … just the slightest bit doddering now. … Still, when one gets her talking about her authors! She gave me a mad sell for Charlie Baxter’s latest. …
August 15: Shirley Hazzard is here for a couple of days. I sat beside her at dinner and we talked of Fran [Kiernan] and Mary [McCarthy], whom she remembers with a slight shudder as “always looking for trouble.” She recalled the time Mary came up to Francis Steegmuller and Alfred Kazin to say, to [Steegmuller], “I’m speaking to you again,” only to turn to Kazin and say, “But not to you.”
August 17: [Carl Phillips’ afternoon reading]: He’s an elusive, appealing guy. Black, gay, superior—and with a right to be: he knows what he wants to do with his poetry, and he does half of it with syntax. Classical, restrained, complicated, very erotic and slyly funny. He’s the great new racehorse in Eddie and Ellen’s formalist corral.
August 18: Dinner down at the Waybury Inn with Howard Norman … and Jane Shore, who reminisced about being a Radcliffe Institute Fellow and showing up at Elizabeth Bishop’s office (this was in ’71) wearing hot pants. … Howard and Jane’s daughter Emma, who’s about 13, asked what hot pants are.
August 19: Carl Phillips lectured this morning on the poetry of Herbert and the sound of “Love (III)” echoed off whatever speck of my brain it’s been stored in for thirty years. A lovely way to begin the morning.
Howard Norman’s strangely intense Fellow, Patricia Eakins, read with [Jenny Egan]—a novel drawn from slave narratives. She’s white and has apparently gotten some flack for trespassing on black-owned territory. She asked me about her problem the other night. So I gave her the obvious response: should Carl Phillips not lecture on Herbert?
For once no evening reading. Just the Vermont Symphony Trio, which we all skipped. I went into Middlebury with Ellen [Bryant Voigt], Eddie, Andrea, Jim Longenbach and Carl Phillips for dinner at the Stone Café … high-level conversation, thanks mostly to Ellen, who pretty much insists on it. We talked about why most of the best postwar American novelists were really better at nonfiction and who the dumbest poets of that period were (Richard Eberhardt). On the ride home Ellen told stories about Helen Vendler and Jorie Graham that betrayed such a deep and baroque interpretation of their career moves that we all had to start laughing.
August 20: [An evening reading by Michele Wyrebek, a Fellow who would die in 2003]: she’s been racked by pain and cancer for more than half her life. She’s twisted and gaunt and has dark circles under her eyes, but she has gone to everyone’s readings, given conferences she didn’t have to, and felt triumphant about being a Fellow. She will more than likely never be here again. But she is the real thing. Her poems naturally enough involve her illness, but they pass even the Ellen test for form and tautness. There’s no self-indulgent “spillage,” to use an EBV-ism. I started out being moved by her presence at the podium and ended up being moved by her language.
2001
August 15: The house lights [in the theatre] are being kept lower than in the past, and after 75 years they’ve cushioned the seats. …
August 16: The first workshop was fine—all these manuscripts set in 11th-century Spain or 17th-century Germany! … Andrea read in the afternoon. Her soft, beautiful recitation of “The Cure” was interrupted by a scream from extreme-urban Vivian Gornick, who saw a chipmunk skittering past her feet. Barry Lopez followed with a passable story and some unbearably kneejerk Bush-bashing, all done in the priestly tones of James Lipton interviewing an actor.
I honestly think [Ellen] is becoming our own John Donne. Wonderful, cerebral, tough poems that she reads with her Southern rasp, chewing through the vowels like pieces of tough meat. … “If truth is not a thing apart from me, / then I don’t want it.”
August 18: At breakfast [David Shields] admitted to me that a lot of [what he read last night] was fiction … so much for all the appreciative laughter and applause he got for being so candid.
The workshop went fine—I was protective of a girl who doesn’t seem to realize she’s writing romance fiction.
Ellen startled me by asking who my literary executor is. I must look more endangered than I think.
August 19: Dinner across from Lynn [Freed], thank God; then another bad, assertive poet before Joan Silber read a long, mournful AIDS story, which I liked. The rather preposterous Rabih Alameddine (Koolaids), sitting behind me, would not applaud, presumably because Joan was trespassing onto his own sacred grounds of victimization.
August 20: [At the evening reading]: Well-crafted, dead poems; language put over everything like two or three layers of thin blanket. No anger, barely any affect at all. [The poet] made a serious study of Zen and then had a 3-year-long writer’s block. Well, don’t go suppressing the ego if you still want to be an author.
I realize that what’s missing—aside from Eddie and Dickie and Andrea—is the pond. It’s been wiped out, first by flood and then by drought. And the drought has nixed the bonfires that used to be lit by its edges. That’s where I used to get a little bit hammered and feel a romantic lift. The drought has also driven the mice indoors in search of something to drink. I’m pretty sure I’ve heard them cavorting in the walls of Maple.
August 21: [One of the Fellows] gave a dreamily weak reading after supper; one of those woozy present-tense affairs that turns action into a form of description. She was followed by Vivian Gornick—who is suspicious, aggressive, impossible, but who gave a powerhouse reading from an old memoir called Fierce Attachments.
August 22: [the morning lecture]: Actually, a barking farrago of meaningless, sentimentalized crap about writing, delivered in a platform manner combining an elderly sage with Mr. Rogers. Lynn Freed and I were nearly gasping for breath; in order to survive, we passed notes back and forth.
August 22: … David Baker and Joan Silber and I went off into the field to look at the night sky: Mars hung bright and low and orange in it, and the spiral arm of the Milky Way was so thick and discernible. … From there we went over to the bonfire: the local authorities finally relented and said it could be lit.
August 23: Vivian Gornick lectured after breakfast. In her way, she’s a truthteller—at least about literature. Knows good writing from bad, doesn’t allow politics to contaminate her judgments. … She’s touching, too, in the ad hoc way she puts together a life with no money at all. But I had a lot of her today, and in the end she wears you out: you spend as much energy fearing the surges of bad Vivian as she spends reining bad V. in. … Conversation at one point turned to Laura Bush’s plugs for [my novel Henry and Clara], and I feared that Vivian might take off like a Russian Mig, but all was okay.
August 24: … Up in the control booth of the theatre, with Michael, Ellen and Tony [Nelson]. Sally and David, the contributing staffers who run it, served us martinis, and whenever [X], the full-of-himself young poet, hit an especially awful line, we hit the button on the King Kong doll that sniffs the air and then roars with anger. We sat there hooting in soundproofed (more or less) contentment.
August 25: If teaching could always have been like this! But it couldn’t: there’s a difference between 13 days and 13 weeks; here they show up zealous, prepared, unfailingly—because they’re ambitious, because they’re grown-ups, because they’re paying their own money. None of those things could ever have been true at Vassar [where I taught for many years].
The last reading slot belonged to Arthur Sze who read these imagistic poems that even Ellen could not penetrate. He would isolate the images with nods of his head or these little tamping-down movements of his palms, sort of like Ann-Margret’s old dancing routine.
2003
August 12: Ellen theorized about how Peter Davison’s slam in Sunday’s Times, all about Eddie’s supposed “retreat toward prose” was, of course, really about P. D.’s long since beaten retreat to the same place.
Sat out with [Eddie] and Carol and a couple of others on the porch at Birch. There’s a robin’s nest in the tree right in front of it—the mama came back with food for the hatchlings who raised their beaks, like staple removers, skyward. Thrilling.
August 14: Paula Fox was the afternoon’s “special guest.” She read from her memoir in a voice deeper than Lauren Bacall’s (emphysema, she later explained to Andrea). She’s 80 years old and still quite beautiful. Steve Orlen asked her if it’s true, as he read in the newspapers, that she had an affair with Marlon Brando—[and] that he is really the grandfather of Courtney Love, of whom PF (quite truly, believe it or not) is the grandmother. PF sweetly responded (I was told): “Did they say anything about Alan Ladd?”
August 15: I’m having fun, spending a lot of time with Eddie and with wonderful Trish Hampl—and with Andrea, who came up and sat on my porch this afternoon. We talked in very low tones, knowing from all our times here how far the breezes carry one’s words.
August 16: Up until midnight … with Michael, Ellen, Charlie, Eddie and a couple of others. Michael and Eddie told James Dickey stories that were so loudly funny no one would get up for refills. One didn’t want to miss anything. So everybody went home happy, tired and undrunk.
August 17: In the evening it got worse. [X] bellowed her slack-verbed poems of self-delight and empowerment, and [Y] read something from a novel set in the 1860s that was no better than a script for Bonanza. Appalling, really.
And then there were the waiters—more full of themselves than ever. Whooping their approval of one another and lapping up the appreciative oohs and mmm-mmm-mmms from the audience. Yes, the late-evening readings are supposed to be fun (despite their also being One More Thing to do), but how are these kids supposed to learn the simple conventions and decorum of reading in public? Do they leave here thinking this is normal? That, instead of silence, as after one movement of a symphony, each poem should be greeted with applause?
Back in Treman [the faculty lounge] all the regulars and veterans grumbled and made cruel fun of what we’d been put through—much of the time looking over our shoulders.
August 19: Now how exactly do you lecture on technique in “The Windhover”—including its rhyme scheme—when you don’t know that “chevalier” is pronounced cheva-leer and not like Maurice Chevalier?
A.B. read from a story called “The Other Williamsburg,” in which she has her revenge on that guitar-playing neighbor she endured in Brooklyn.
August 20: After Charlie’s morning lecture on the disappearance of faces and physiognomy from fiction, and then three more student conferences, I had to wait tables in the dining hall of the Inn with my faculty colleagues—the annual role-reversal. (As if the waiters don’t already get enough attention.) I remember this as a lark a couple of years ago, but it exhausted me today—rushing around with the huge trays (some of them loaded with the ghastliest vegetarian concoction ever), hunting up soy milk for someone who required it for her tea. I had sweated through my shirt—exhaustion and fever both—by the time I was through.
August 21: Feeling a little better, though this cold isn’t going away anytime soon. I’m no more exhausted than anyone else, though. Certainly not Michael, who was up most of the night arranging the conference’s first expulsion (a crazy Irish waiter).
Late at night, crossing the path near the bookstore: a beautiful, full-tailed fox.
August 22: Jay Parini tells me that he spoke to Gore [Vidal] on the phone last night (he’s in LA, where Howard is dying) and told him about my move to Washington. “It’ll be the death of him as a writer,” he said, with a sympathy subordinate to his delight in the subject, on which Jay says he did 45 minutes. The only writer who ever survived adult residence in Washington [according to Gore]? Elinor Wylie. I’ll risk it.
Crossed the road back to Maple with Ellen—and we saw a shooting star.
Naeem Murr—my delightful, soft-spoken, tactful Fellow—was one of the afternoon readers, and he hit it out of the park with a chapter from his second novel, The Genius of the Sea … [followed by someone] whose verse was indistinguishable from prose—so blandly denotative that had it been prose, one’s criticism of it would have been the near-total absence of figurative language.
August 24: Ate a fast breakfast with Charlie (who loves being jollied out of his own reserve and darker moods), shared an intense embrace with Michael—and was on my way. Very nearly cried as the van pulled away, determined never to forget how good this place has been for—and to—me.
2004
August 11: During the cocktail hour at Treman, Carol H. S. asked [Julia Alvarez] about her coffee “plantation.” Julia corrected her and said it was a coffee “farm” (presumably less imperialist), and then smilingly told Carol that at Bread Loaf we “must pay attention to language.”
I’ve decided to go on the Two-Step program—drinking one night, not drinking the next.
August 12: It’s always peculiar meeting the people whose manuscripts you’ve been reading. I’m sometimes afraid I’ll say, “I thought you’d be better looking.”
An odd incident. A few moments after I’d said something about Ulysses, the spectral “man in the mackintosh” showed up. I’m not kidding: a bald, gnomish old man wearing a yellow slicker came all the way into the classroom and stood, silently, watching us. It was so creepy I couldn’t even make myself say, “Can I help you?”
August 13: [A conference with] Pierce Graham-Jones, a baby-faced Middlebury undergraduate whose manuscript ended with Britney Spears inserting her fingers into the vagina of the heroine—on the moon. It’s “meta-fiction,” he told me.
August 14: Spencer Reece, the 41-year-old poet who works at Brooks Brothers and has recently been written up everywhere, read a strong, beautiful poem about his family’s home on Cape Cod. It was spoiled only by too much platform patter and theatrics. He cries, I believe, at every reading.
August 18: Went to the bonfire just before bed, even though I was much too tired. Had a beer and talked to Matthew Power, a cute, ambitious young man who’s been running to one hot spot and another for Harper’s.
August 21: The food has generally been better than last year, but the farewell banquet, sometimes the only good meal of the conference, was ghastly this year—like something out of a high-school cafeteria. Michael actually had me photograph the entree, as evidence—to be presented to the trustees, I suppose.
… no real scandal at the dance—unless you count the married … assistant professor who’s hooked up with two women this week, telling them there’s no problem presented by his marriage, since he’s bisexual, and when he’s with a woman other than his wife he imagines that she’s a guy. (Paging Gov. McGreevey.) Of course tonight he was on the prowl for the real thing—a whippet-thin Asian boy, one of the waiters.
The waiters had a ton of extra liquor in their horrible frat-house lair, and I helped carry some of it over to Treman for the last after-hours party, which went on until three. Among the booze bottles were two of “Buttershots”—a nauseating butterscotch liqueur that could soon be smelled everywhere. Jason Schneiderman gulped down three half-glasses of it and in a matter of seconds got drunk before my eyes.
2005
August 16: … Having a cocktail on the porch at Treman by 6:15. All my dearest: Andrea, Ellen, Charlie, Michael. Lynn comes later tonight, Eddie tomorrow. Tony Nelson is here for a few days too. Next to Tom Sleigh (now divorced) at dinner. In love with the absolute familiarity of the place, the breezes and temperatures thirty degrees below what we had in Washington.
August 18: So far the poetry has been grim—the world-refusing Louise Glück and Catherine Barnett (children dying in a plane crash)—and the fiction comic (Francine and Lynn Freed, with whom I’m sharing nearly every meal).
August 19: Lunch next to Louise … Unbearable. How many ways can the world find to let her down? I wind up making a parody of her poetry for Eddie … on the way to the theatre (“To my bare, bruised feet / The world offered a carpet / And I said no.”)
August 20: Trish’s lecture, about reading Katherine Mansfield as a young woman, was just wonderful—as always, the best thing one hears up here, a beautiful blend of narrative and criticism.
… [For once] I can’t stand my Fellow … this morning, during the workshop, he got up to write on the blackboard while I was still speaking. There’s always an All About Eve moment in these workshops. …
August 21: Had three conferences in the Barn (the DC lawyer who’s rushing home for a trial; the computer guy who’s made his pile before 40 out in San Francisco and is now giving himself a couple of years just to write; the young mother with her Harvard degree and film-industry experience who’s just moved to Santa Fe).
The first dance … Charlie got sweetly, geekily drunk; his spirits have risen since his son got here. Eddie claimed that he was looking for an “imaginary threesome,” and Michael got sentimental when all of us—me, him, Eddie, Andrea, Charlie—were sitting in Treman at one in the morning. I did, too. Not a bad generation of writers and friends, I must say.
August 22: [My reading from Fellow Travelers]: The piece was a huge success with Ellen, whose judgment counts for a lot with me—partly because she’s willing to withhold approbation from even her nearest and dearest if she doesn’t think the work warrants it.
August 24: Lynn F. gave a funny and slightly chilling lecture about all the false starts she made on one of her novels, The Bungalow. Chilling for all the blithe, slapdash “advice” one gets from editors and agents who haven’t given two minutes’ thought to what they’re telling the writer.
… It was time for us [the faculty] to wait tables in the dining room. Why exactly we should this year have to do this turnabout is a mystery, since the waiters have hardly been waiting on us. Lunch is now just a cafeteria line. But I suppose it was worth it for the sight of Lynn [a white South African] wearing an apron and carrying a tray: “Mr. Mandela always said this day would come,” I told her.
August 25: Gerald Stern followed [Andrea] to the podium: genial, but work full of . . . self-congratulation upon his own humanity. In a poem about a black flower salesman, the speaker tells us that this man is missing half his teeth and “therefore I love him.”
2008
August 16: Ted Conover read. … His musings upon the overharvesting of mahogany only made Lynn crave a new bureau. (She has forbidden her students to write about “our planet.”)
August 18: Skipped the picnic out at the Frost cabin, which was much in the news several months ago, when it was trashed by local kids. (They were sentenced to a couple of seminars on Frost with Jay Parini.)
August 19: Cold, rainy; the wind whips and whistles through the wraparound porches of Maple. Everyone’s bundled in fleece.
August 20: Dean Young began the day with one of his lectures in praise of surrealism. Every time I hear him I feel an urge to go out and punctuate the world, to impose order and couplets and alexandrines upon it.
August 22: Jim Longenbach lectured very well on something he called “poetic amplitude,” which as nearly as I can gather means prosiness.
August 23: [At the Burlington airport]: As I sat at the gate with André Bernard, one last student asked me to recommend an agent for her.
2009
August 13: Lynn Freed blew the roof off the theatre with a … relentless story about the rape and revenge of a savage girl plucked away from life with the baboons. No humor, no charm, just calm and incidentally descriptive narrative of one horror after another. … She stopped everyone cold.
August 16: After a couple of conferences, I was back in the theatre with Charlie to do a panel: me, him and Dan [Frank, my editor], who’d just driven over from the Adirondacks and was here for the first time in 11 years. The 3 of us spoke about longstanding publishing relationships—i.e., each of ours with Dan—and told affectionate, illustrative stories. The audience clearly thought of me and Charlie as lucky bastards, and I was thinking the same thing myself. We were all talking about a publishing model that has practically disappeared and which most of them will never experience.
August 18: We are all covered with bug bites, a misery even greater than the 90-degree heat is providing. This particular plague stems from the decimation of the local bat population by some white fungus. The bats are essential to keeping down the mosquitoes, whom they apparently devour by the millions. Whatever the case, we’re all scratching and miserable.
[Ellen’s] new work more playful than the old. God, what strength, though, to the attack of her lines; she tricks you into thinking that even the ones without verbs actually have them.
2012
August 16: The weather’s lovely; the bats are back and mosquito population is down.
The theatre was jammed by 8:15—and for the first time ever I heard a cell phone go off in there … a bit of service, quite spotty, has arrived on the mountain. It will not improve things.
Eavan Boland read some crisp poems about the Irish famine and Peter Ho Davies’s British accent and performing instincts kept him heard above the rains that suddenly started pouring down upon the roof.
Scott Russell Sanders gave the first lecture this morning: a Wendell Berryish paean to goodness and against global warming. … He was showing the power of imagination to defeat evil, the way it defeated slavery. (No mention of the Union dead.)
Sweet, beautiful and now heavily-laureled Jenny Egan did a guest reading from the Goon Squad book. Lovely to see her, and to talk afterwards over cocktails, but she went on for a solid hour, and I thought I was going to pass out in the upper reaches of the overheated theatre.
… the first RMW chapter [that I read] from Watergate went over very well. (Afterwards a sweet young thing asked me if Rose Mary Woods was an actual person.)
All the male waiters seem “inked” to a fare-thee-well. At least they’ve cleaned up their living quarters in that almost underground warren near the barn. It used to be that you could go in there wearing boots and come out with athlete’s foot.
August 17: Lynn lectured on the subject of writers getting old—and experiencing an ever-more-acute need of peace and quiet. Very funny, wise, personal, crisp—leavened with just the right amount of the literary anecdotal. She shocked the more pious elements of the audience with the confession that she’d recently slapped her 42-year-old daughter across the face. They expected this revelation to be followed by a rote expression of guilt and penitence—which never came. (At lunch, I sat with her and one of her students, who made an awed remark about the gulf between the “contributors” and faculty in the workshops. “Properly so,” Lynn replied.)
August 20: Exhaustion set in after lunch. I tried napping, and did, but no good came of it; I was just as tired when I got up. And of course it’s not easy to sleep in the noisy crackerbox that is Maple—this fantastic New Orleans-style pile-up of a house, sort of like the Belle Rive of Ripton.
August 20: … Over at cocktails, just after we took the faculty photo, Jay Parini told me that Gerry Howard is probably going to have to cancel the memorial service for Gore [Vidal], which he was planning for October 7. No one will agree to speak! … So Gerry may instead try to put together some sort of panel discussion at the NYPL. … It’s like some story told by the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come: let this be a warning to you—be nicer, or you get a panel discussion instead of a memorial service.
[Linda Gregerson] read some witty poems inspired by Ovid. Very strong stuff. Trish and Lynn and I had a drink with her at Treman afterwards and were just about the only ones there. Almost nobody stays up late anymore, because we’re all growing old.
O Loaf! You’ve given me such joy over the years. And yet I do think it may be time for me, too, to wrap things up on the mountain. To begin a graceful descent from it, with fine memories of all of us in our primes.
August 21: I devoted a portion of today’s two hours [of the workshop] to the periodic sentence and climactic syntax—and they seemed absolutely to love this arcane stuff.
I love being around Lynn and Trish, but it’s a little like being a man with two wives. I spend lots of time waiting for them to get ready—to change outfits, etc.—before we go off to the next event together. Tonight, before dinner, it was the lawn party at Treman, where I did sell a lot of books. Common signing refrain with Watergate: “Would you sign this for my father?”
August 24: One last workshop. (“Why does this story remind us of the years 1977–81?” I asked the students. “Because it’s got a protagonist named Carter who isn’t big enough for the circumstances he’s in.”)
2016
August 9: Lots of changes—even an elevator in the renovated Inn! Railings on the old bannisters and porches; curbs; a defibrillator near the front desk.
August 10: Everyone is here, and it’s deafening. The new ceiling in the dining room is pretty, but it’s an awful acoustical blunder that they’re going to have to replace. Lynn and I ate dinner with David Shields and Garth Greenwell … and at one point things were so loud that she had to write down what she was saying.
August 11: Lynn and Trish were early to bed. I drank vodka on the porch with Jen Grotz and ageless Patrick Phillips, who’s up from NY. There was supposed to be a meteor shower at 1 a.m., but it was impossible to imagine staying up that late.
August 13: [Alan Shapiro’s reading] He’s letting himself be pissed off instead of cosmically angry, and it makes for a much better wild-wicked-old-man phase.
August 14: Two Barn conferences: the Fellow who was twice a contestant on Survivor and the woman whose father was an active Nazi sympathizer.
August 15: I’ve never run the 2.75-mile Writer’s Cramp race—always held the morning after the first dance—until today. All around the campus, down to the Frost farm and back. I finished ahead of two Contributors in my workshop, I’ll have you know …
August 16: One thing I’ve been realizing about so many of the young politically-correct poets here: they turn the old description of the metaphysicals upside-down. They apprehend feeling as thought.